Recent Posts
Selecting a seal strength tester requires more than checking its maximum load capacity. The useful force range must cover the weakest and strongest expected seals, the grips must hold the actual package materials without changing how they fail, and the drive must maintain the speed specified by the test method. A machine that meets only one of these conditions can produce numbers that look credible but are difficult to reproduce or compare.
The most reliable selection starts with the intended specimen and test procedure, not with a catalogue capacity. Pharmaceutical pouches, flexible plastic films and high-barrier laminates can impose very different demands on force measurement, gripping and travel, even when all are described as heat-sealed packaging.
Seal strength is commonly evaluated by pulling two components of a sealed specimen apart and recording the force. The reported result may be a force per unit width, a peak force, an average force over a defined region, or another value specified by the method. These are not interchangeable measures. A peak can capture an isolated strong point, while an average may better represent the force across a selected portion of a peel. The appropriate output depends on the applicable procedure and the purpose of the measurement.
Before comparing equipment, establish the specimen width, expected force, separation direction, grip arrangement and required test speed. Also identify whether the seal is expected to peel cleanly or whether the material may stretch, tear or delaminate. These details determine not only which load cell is needed, but also whether the fixture, available travel and software can support the test.
ASTM F88/F88M is a commonly referenced method for seal strength of flexible barrier materials. It includes different specimen support techniques, so a tester should be assessed against the technique and procedure actually selected rather than a general claim that it can perform an ASTM F88 test. Obtain and use the applicable edition, and check any customer or internal requirements that further define specimen preparation, speed, reporting and conditioning.
A strength result should not be treated as a direct leak or package-integrity result. A seal can resist a tensile separation test yet still require a separate integrity assessment. Conversely, a peel-strength measurement is valuable for characterizing seal performance, but its interpretation depends on the material system and the failure mode.
Maximum capacity describes the upper limit of a load cell or machine configuration; it does not establish how well the system measures small forces. For a weak, narrow seal, the relevant question is whether the expected force lies within the manufacturer’s stated calibrated measurement range and accuracy at that reading. A high-capacity cell may offer ample overload headroom while providing an unsuitable lower measurement limit for the application.
Start with the expected force per unit width and multiply by specimen width to estimate total force. For example, a seal expected to produce 2 N per 15 mm strip will place approximately 2 N on the load cell for that strip width; a 30 mm strip at the same nominal strength would produce approximately 4 N. This is a sizing estimate, not a prediction of actual test results: seal uniformity, material behavior and failure mode can change the force.
Allow for realistic variation and transient peaks, not just a nominal average. A seal with a modest average peel force may have a sharp initiation peak, while an unexpectedly strong seal can exceed the working range before the test stops. At the low end, include the weakest acceptable specimens, not only typical production material. If the application spans a wide range, interchangeable load cells may be more appropriate than selecting one cell solely for the strongest sample.
Accuracy statements require close reading. An instrument specified as accurate to a percentage of the indicated force is not directly comparable with one specified as a percentage of full-scale capacity. For example, an error limit expressed as a percentage of a 500 N full scale has a much larger absolute value than the same percentage of a 5 N reading. Check the stated lower limit, resolution, calibration interval and the conditions under which the specification applies. Display resolution alone is not evidence of measurement accuracy.
Also distinguish load-cell capacity from the rated capacity of the grips, fixtures and machine frame. The usable system limit is constrained by the lowest-rated component in the load path. Overload protection and an appropriate stop strategy matter when an operator may select the wrong cell or test a specimen stronger than expected.
Even a well-calibrated force sensor cannot correct for a specimen that slips or is damaged in the jaws. Slippage changes the effective movement of the specimen and can reduce or distort the measured force. Excessive clamping pressure can cut a film, crush a porous layer or create a premature break outside the seal. Either outcome makes the result difficult to interpret.
Grip faces should match the materials being held. Thin, smooth films may need a surface that prevents slipping without marking or tearing the specimen. Porous, coated or delicate layers may require a different jaw face or pressure setting. Pneumatic grips can provide controlled clamping when supplied and set up correctly, while mechanical grips offer another approach; neither type is automatically superior for every material. The relevant evidence is whether the chosen arrangement holds the specimen consistently without creating damage.
Jaw width and alignment deserve the same attention as jaw material. The faces must accommodate the specimen width and grip length, while holding both legs square to the direction of pull. Uneven clamping can introduce twisting or concentrate stress at one edge. Record or control the initial jaw separation as required by the method, because it affects the amount of free material available to stretch and move before and during separation.
For pouch seals, access to two usable tails is a practical constraint. Short tails may not reach the grips securely, and a rigid or curled laminate may resist alignment. The fixture must leave enough room for the specimen to separate without rubbing against the frame or a grip. If a method requires one leg to be supported, folded or held in a particular orientation, confirm that the grip and fixture can reproduce that arrangement without relying on an operator to improvise.
The observed failure mode should be captured alongside the force trace. Seal separation, film rupture, layer delamination and slipping in a grip can produce very different curves, even when their peak values are similar. A material break is not automatically an invalid result, but it must be interpreted under the applicable method and specification; it does not provide the same information as a clean peel through the seal.
Seal strength can depend on separation rate because polymers, adhesives and laminates respond to deformation over time. Changing the crosshead speed can change the measured peak, the shape of the force curve or the way the specimen fails. Results obtained at different speeds should therefore not be assumed comparable, even when specimen width and force units match.
Check that the tester can run at the required speed under load, not merely display that value as a setpoint. The relevant specification includes speed range, control accuracy and stability for the expected force and travel. Ask how the drive behaves at the beginning of the test: acceleration and take-up of slack can influence a short test or an initiation peak. A machine’s nominal maximum speed is of little value if it cannot control the lower speed required by the procedure.
Crosshead travel is equally important. The machine must accommodate the initial grip separation, specimen extension and the length of seal separation, with clearance for the fixtures. Highly extensible films can consume substantial travel before the seal opens. In a long peel test, insufficient travel may end the run before the force has been recorded over the intended region.
Crosshead speed should also not be confused with the actual speed of the peel front. The latter is affected by specimen geometry, angle and deformation. Maintaining the prescribed crosshead speed is necessary for a controlled method, but a change in grip setup or specimen support can still change the mechanics of separation.
A single reported number can conceal problems that are visible in the force-versus-displacement or force-versus-time curve. A sharp initial spike may reflect seal initiation, but it may also be influenced by slack, alignment or the way the specimen was mounted. Repeated drops can indicate intermittent peel, tearing or slippage. The shape alone does not prove the cause; it provides a reason to inspect the specimen and the setup.
Software should therefore support the calculation specified by the method and retain the underlying data. Check whether the operator can define the portion of the curve used for an average, exclude a specified initiation region when permitted, record specimen width and preserve units. The system should make the calculation and any excluded data traceable rather than silently applying an unknown default.
Data acquisition and filtering also affect the result. A short-lived peak can be understated if the acquisition rate is too low or if filtering smooths it excessively. Conversely, an unfiltered signal may include noise that is mistaken for a meaningful maximum. Evaluate the rate and filtering settings against the speed of the test and the output being reported, and keep those settings consistent when comparing results.
For regulated or controlled quality systems, determine what records the site actually requires: instrument identification, calibration status, method settings, raw data, operator identification and any controls on changes to results. Software features should be assessed against those requirements; an electronic report by itself does not establish compliance with a particular regulation.
A useful evaluation uses representative specimens across the intended force range, including difficult-to-grip materials and seals likely to show different failure modes. Prepare specimens consistently, condition them as required by the applicable method, and use the same width, grip arrangement, initial separation, speed and calculation rules on each candidate system. Record any unavoidable differences rather than treating the instruments as equivalent by default.
Review more than the average force. Examine the spread of results, the force curves, the failure locations and any signs of jaw damage or slipping. If two systems disagree, check specimen preparation and setup before attributing the difference to load-cell accuracy. Different grip surfaces, support techniques, speed control or software averaging regions can all produce a meaningful change in the reported value.
The final choice should be the configuration that covers the required measurement range and reproduces the specified test geometry with acceptable control—not simply the system with the highest capacity or widest speed range. Where one configuration cannot handle both weak films and stronger seals without compromising measurement or handling, separate cells or fixtures may be necessary to keep results defensible.
Leave A Reply
Search by Keywords


